Selectivity Between Main and Feeder Breakers
Fault on one feeder should darken one feeder, not the building. Selectivity is the calculation that makes that true, and it is done on curves, not on ratings.
Two kinds of selectivity
Current selectivity uses the difference in instantaneous trip thresholds: the downstream breaker trips magnetically before the upstream one sees the fault. Time selectivity uses a deliberate delay in the upstream device — an adjustable short-time delay on the main — so both see the fault but only the downstream one acts. Time selectivity is more reliable and requires an electronic trip unit upstream, which is why it appears mostly on larger boards.
The ratio rule of thumb
For moulded case breakers without adjustable trips, a ratio of 1.6:1 between upstream and downstream ratings often gives current selectivity, but only in the region where the downstream breaker trips instantaneously. Above that, the curves overlap and selectivity is lost. The only proof is to lay the manufacturer's curves one above the other and check the overlap.
Where selectivity is abandoned deliberately
At the incomer of a sub-board fed from a main board, a small amount of non-selectivity is normal and accepted. What is not acceptable is claiming full selectivity on a drawing without the curves. The incoming breaker note covers the upstream side, and the power distribution cabinet is supplied with the coordination study when the fault level is provided.
